Skip to content

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Mobile and Baldwin County News

Latest

Crime Mobile

Judge Weighs IQ Evidence in Euclid Avenue Barbershop Killings as Michael Stone Seeks to Avoid Death Penalty

A Mobile County judge will decide whether Michael Terrell Stone, charged in a deadly 2024 barbershop robbery, has an intellectual disability that rules out a death sentence after prosecutors challenged a defense psychologist's findings.

Empty courtroom witness stand beside stacks of psychological records and a judge's bench
A Mobile County circuit judge is weighing psychological records and IQ testing before deciding whether a capital murder defendant can face execution.

MOBILE, Ala. — Whether Michael Terrell Stone can face execution if he is convicted now rests with Mobile County Circuit Judge Vicki Davis, who heard a day of sharply contested psychological testimony on Friday, Nov. 13, and held off on ruling. Stone, a 22-year-old Mobile man charged with capital murder in a 2024 robbery that left two people dead, is asking the court to find that he has an intellectual disability, a finding that would rule out the death penalty in his case.

The judge gave prosecutors and defense lawyers time to file additional written arguments before she decides the question. Stone has not been tried on the underlying charges, and he is presumed innocent unless and until he is convicted.

The Crime at the Heart of the Case

Stone is one of two men accused in a robbery that turned deadly in 2024 in the 600 block of Euclid Avenue in Mobile. The shooting happened inside a backyard shed that had been turned into a barbershop. Two people were killed and two others were wounded.

His co-defendant, Santoine Johnson, is also charged with capital murder. Johnson’s lawyers have raised the same kind of claim, arguing that he too has an intellectual deficiency that should bar a death sentence. A hearing on Johnson’s claim is scheduled for January.

What the Defense Experts Told the Court

Two psychologists testified on Stone’s behalf. Their accounts centered on a long paper trail that, according to the defense, documents Stone’s struggles going back to early childhood.

An IQ Score Below 70

A clinical psychologist who evaluated Stone told the court that he gave Stone an IQ test in 2025 and that Stone scored 68. He said he had reviewed hundreds of pages of records drawn from four sources: the Mobile County public school system, the Strickland Youth Center, Mobile County Metro Jail and AltaPointe Health, the regional behavioral health provider.

The psychologist said it is unusual for him to have that much documentation on a criminal defendant. In his account, Stone’s school recorded his academic difficulties at a very young age, and the records show those difficulties continuing throughout his life. He testified that his own conclusions lined up with the results of earlier evaluations, and explained that experts in his field look for that kind of consistency, along with any results that do not fit the pattern.

Deficits Traced to Age 5

A second psychologist, one who is frequently asked by the state to examine criminal defendants, appeared for the defense in this case. He testified that Stone has shown deficiencies in adaptive functioning, the practical everyday skills that clinicians weigh alongside IQ, since he was 5 years old.

The Records Behind the Claim

Each of the record sources cited at the hearing reflects a different stage of Stone’s life. School system files can include special education evaluations, test results and individualized education programs. The Strickland Youth Center is home to Mobile County’s juvenile court and juvenile detention operations, so its records can cover a young person’s contact with the juvenile justice system. AltaPointe Health is a nonprofit behavioral health system serving Mobile and Baldwin counties, and Mobile County Metro Jail is the county’s main adult detention facility, operated by the sheriff’s office.

Taken together, records like these can help a court judge whether problems with learning and daily living were present years before a defendant was charged, which is one of the core issues in any intellectual disability claim.

The State’s Challenge

Prosecutors from the Mobile County District Attorney’s Office went after the first psychologist’s methods and track record during a pointed cross-examination.

  • Omitted evaluations: An assistant district attorney asked why his report left out earlier evaluations that had placed Stone’s intellectual ability at a higher level.
  • A prior ruling: She confronted him with a decision in a separate case in which a judge rejected his conclusions about a defendant as lacking credibility. He responded that the earlier case dealt with competency, a different legal question, and that comparing the two was not a fair match.
  • A pattern of findings: The prosecutor told the court that the district attorney’s office has pursued the death penalty seven times over the past five years and that this psychologist found an intellectual development disorder in every one of those defendants.
  • Siding with the defense: Asked why his opinions so often favor defendants, the psychologist said his findings frequently cut against the people he evaluates, but defense attorneys put him on the stand only when his reports help their clients.

The District Attorney’s Position

The district attorney said his office is confident Stone is eligible to face a death sentence. He said prosecutors have grown concerned in recent years about defendants being placed right at, or just below, the threshold for intellectual disability in ways the office believes are not supported. To counter that, he said, the office hired an outside expert to examine the defense reports, and much of that review was presented during Friday’s hearing.

Why Intellectual Disability Matters in a Death Penalty Case

The dispute traces back to a 2002 decision of the U.S. Supreme Court, Atkins v. Virginia, which held that executing a person with an intellectual disability violates the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment. The justices left it largely to the states to work out how courts should decide who meets that definition, which is why the question is resolved one defendant at a time.

Later rulings narrowed how states may apply that rule. In Hall v. Florida in 2014, the Supreme Court said a state cannot treat an IQ score above 70 as an automatic cutoff without accounting for the test’s margin of error. In Moore v. Texas in 2017, the court said states must be guided by current medical standards rather than outdated or lay stereotypes about intellectual disability.

How Alabama Courts Weigh the Claim

Alabama courts generally look at three elements when a capital defendant raises an intellectual disability claim:

  • Intellectual functioning: significantly below-average intelligence, usually measured through standardized IQ testing, with scores around 70 or below drawing the closest attention.
  • Adaptive behavior: significant deficits in the skills people use to manage daily life, such as communication, self-care, social interaction, schoolwork and handling money.
  • Age of onset: evidence that both problems appeared during the developmental period, before adulthood.

The defendant carries the burden of proving the claim. That is why records created long before any criminal charge, such as school files, juvenile records and treatment histories, often become central evidence. They can show whether the problems existed in childhood or emerged only after a defendant faced the possibility of a death sentence.

Competency Is a Separate Question

The back-and-forth over the earlier ruling touched on a distinction that often comes up in criminal courts. A competency determination asks whether a defendant currently understands the proceedings against him and can assist his lawyers. An intellectual disability claim under Atkins asks a different question about lifelong intellectual and adaptive functioning. A person can be competent to stand trial and still be found to have an intellectual disability, and the reverse is also possible.

Weighing Competing Experts

Hearings of this kind often turn on which experts a judge finds more persuasive. When psychologists disagree, the trial judge decides how much weight to give each opinion, considering factors such as the testing methods used, whether all available records were reviewed and how an expert’s conclusions compare with earlier evaluations. Appellate courts in Alabama generally give significant deference to those credibility calls, though they can and do reverse findings they believe the evidence does not support.

That possibility was on display just days before Stone’s hearing. On Nov. 6, the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals restored the death sentence of Michael Bragg Woolf, a Mobile man convicted in the 2008 killings of his wife and young son, after concluding that a Mobile County circuit judge had wrongly found him intellectually disabled. That case involved different facts, records and test scores, but it shows how closely Alabama’s appellate courts review these determinations.

What Happens Next

Once both sides file their written arguments, Judge Davis will decide whether Stone has proven an intellectual disability. If she rules in his favor, prosecutors could not seek the death penalty against him, and the most severe sentence available if he is convicted of capital murder would be life in prison without the possibility of parole.

If the judge rejects the claim, the case would move toward trial with the death penalty still possible. Under current Alabama law, a jury must decide on a death sentence, at least 10 of the 12 jurors must agree to it, and judges can no longer override a jury’s sentencing decision.

The January hearing for Johnson will put the same legal question before the court a second time, with a separate set of records and evaluations.

At a Glance

  • Defendant: Michael Terrell Stone, 22, of Mobile, charged with capital murder
  • Crime: A 2024 robbery in a backyard barbershop shed in the 600 block of Euclid Avenue; two killed, two injured
  • Issue: Whether Stone has an intellectual disability that makes him ineligible for execution
  • Key evidence: A 2025 IQ score of 68 and records from schools, juvenile detention, jail and mental health providers
  • Status: No ruling yet; written arguments to follow
  • Co-defendant: Santoine Johnson, also charged with capital murder; his hearing is set for January

See something? Say something.

Got a news tip?

The best local stories start with readers. Tell our newsroom what is happening in your community.