St. Paul’s Loses QB Hayden Fincher, RB Ty Sellers as Injuries and Illness Mark a ‘Year of Adversity’
St. Paul's football lost quarterback Hayden Fincher and running back Ty Sellers to likely season-ending injuries, while about 20 players have missed time with strep throat. Coach Ham Barnett says the Saints can still finish strong.
MOBILE, Ala. — St. Paul’s football coach Ham Barnett has run out of ways to describe the Saints’ luck this fall. In the span of one week, St. Paul’s lost its starting quarterback and its leading rusher to injuries that will likely end their seasons, and a wave of illness has swept through the roster on top of it.
Junior quarterback Hayden Fincher and sophomore running back Ty Sellers were both hurt in last week’s 39-35 loss to St. Michael Catholic, a game the Saints led by 18 points in the third quarter before the Cardinals rallied to win in the final minutes.
Barnett said he doesn’t know how to explain it, attributing it to a lot of bad luck and calling it a year of adversity.
St. Paul’s (2-3, 1-2 in Private Class AA, Region 1) is off this week. The Saints return to action next Friday, Oct. 2, at Montgomery Catholic.
At a Glance
- Team: St. Paul’s Episcopal Saints, Mobile
- Record: 2-3 overall, 1-2 in Private Class AA, Region 1
- Injured: QB Hayden Fincher (torn ACL) and RB Ty Sellers (ankle), both likely out for the regular season
- Illness: About 20 players have missed time with strep throat over the past two weeks; several others have been out with concussions
- Next game: Friday, Oct. 2, at Montgomery Catholic
- Playoffs: All 16 Private Class AA teams qualify for the postseason
Two Starters Lost in One Night
The St. Michael game on Sept. 18 was a microcosm of the Saints’ season. Fincher left with an injury in the first quarter. Senior Roberts Law stepped in, running out of a Wildcat package the Saints had not practiced with him, and scored four rushing touchdowns. Sellers ran 18 times for 129 yards and a touchdown before leaving late in the third quarter.
Without both players, St. Paul’s could not hold its lead, and St. Michael scored the winning touchdown with 1:09 left.
Sellers’ loss is a major one. The sophomore was twice named the Cunningham Bounds Coastal Player of the Week in the first four weeks of the season. He has run for 606 yards and six touchdowns on 81 carries, an average of about 7.5 yards per attempt. In a 38-33 win at Glenwood, he ran 28 times for 210 yards and two scores as the Saints piled up 422 rushing yards.
Barnett said the one bit of good news is that Sellers will not need surgery on his ankle.
Barnett said those guys have been at practice every day. He added that Ty does not need surgery on his ankle, which is positive, but recovery will take 6-8 weeks, by which time the season will likely be over.
A Frustrating Year for Fincher
Fincher, in his second full season as the Saints’ starting quarterback, had already fought through one injury this fall. He hurt his wrist in the region-opening loss to McGill-Toolen, returned and was playing well before tearing his ACL on a play with no contact.
In that McGill-Toolen game, Fincher showed what he could do, throwing a 90-yard touchdown pass to Bo Ladner and scrambling 46 yards for another score.
Barnett said injuries have plagued Hayden this year: he hurt his wrist against McGill-Toolen, returned to play well, then tore his ACL in a non-contact injury. He noted that Roberts (Law) has stepped up, praised the offensive staff for a great plan, and said players must continue to step up, but he remains confident the team will have a good year.
Strep Throat and Concussions
The injuries to Fincher and Sellers are only part of the story. Barnett said about 20 players have missed time with strep throat over the past two weeks, and several others have been sidelined by concussions.
That kind of attrition is especially hard on a small private-school roster, where many players contribute on both sides of the ball and on special teams. It is one reason Barnett welcomed the timing of the open date.
Barnett said the bye week came at a good time, stressing the need to stay healthy for the final stretch. He believes all remaining games are winnable if the team plays well, and that the team is coming together. He acknowledged they have a good group but are not finishing games, having lost late leads against McGill-Toolen and St. Michael in the fourth quarter, and said they have focused this week on finishing those types of games.
Who Steps In
With Fincher and Sellers out, Barnett said the Saints will lean more on Law and sophomore running back Sam Frazer. Murphy Fromdahl is expected to take over at quarterback.
Law has already proven he can carry a load. Against Glenwood, he ran 18 times for 186 yards and a touchdown. Against St. Michael, with little warning, he gained 108 yards on 15 carries and scored on runs of 1, 2, 6 and 2 yards.
Barnett said the coaching staff will use the off week to build new wrinkles around the players who are healthy.
Barnett said they will devise different packages to gain advantages, adding that the bye week is beneficial and the players will respond well.
A Season of Close Calls
St. Paul’s record hides how competitive its season has been. Before the St. Michael game, the Saints had scored 130 points and allowed 129 through four games.
Their three losses have come against quality opponents. Gulf Shores beat the Saints 34-10 in the season’s opening weeks, the Dolphins’ first win in the series since 2009. McGill-Toolen, ranked No. 2 in Private Class AA, scored the final 14 points to win 34-24 in the region opener after St. Paul’s had taken the lead. Then came the four-point loss to St. Michael after leading by 18.
In between, the Saints won a shootout at Glenwood, running for 422 yards in a 38-33 victory.
The Road Ahead
St. Paul’s has five regular-season games left:
- Friday, Oct. 2: at Montgomery Catholic
- Friday, Oct. 9: vs. Faith Academy
- Friday, Oct. 16: vs. UMS-Wright
- Thursday, Oct. 22: at Houston Academy
- Friday, Oct. 30: vs. Spanish Fort
Montgomery Catholic has already shown it can handle area competition, beating Faith Academy 38-7 earlier this month. UMS-Wright, a Mobile rival of the Saints, was ranked No. 5 in Private Class AA in the Sept. 19 state poll and has beaten both St. Michael and Faith Academy.
The good news for the Saints is that the postseason door remains wide open. All 16 schools in Private Class AA will qualify for the playoffs, which means the rest of the regular season is about getting healthy, finding an identity on offense and building momentum for November.
Barnett on the Public-Private Split
This is the first season under the Alabama High School Athletic Association’s new structure, approved in January, which separates public and private schools into different championship brackets. Public schools now compete in Classes 1A through 6A, while private schools compete in Private Class AA, with 16 schools, and Private Class A, with 28. Regular-season games between public and private schools continue, which is why St. Paul’s still plays Gulf Shores and Spanish Fort.
Barnett said the change has produced good football but a heavy travel burden, because the private schools in the Saints’ classification are spread across the state.
He said every game has been competitive and the season has been pretty good, but travel has been awful, with trips to Glenwood, Montgomery, and Dothan. He noted that in the smaller classification, smaller schools are at a disadvantage, which he doesn’t think is good for program stability.
Glenwood is located in east Alabama near the Georgia line, Montgomery Catholic is in the state capital, and Houston Academy is in Dothan in the Wiregrass, all long bus rides from Mobile.
Barnett said he is still reserving judgment on the new system overall, but he likes the balance within his region.
Barnett said he is still taking a wait-and-see approach, noting that in their league, particularly their region, anyone can beat anyone on a given night, with no team head and shoulders above the rest, which makes it interesting.
About St. Paul’s
St. Paul’s Episcopal School, founded in 1947, is a prekindergarten-through-12th-grade school on Dogwood Lane in Mobile. The Saints have a long record of athletic success across many sports, and the school’s alumni include former Alabama and NFL quarterback A.J. McCarron, NFL safety Mark Barron, NFL defensive end Bryce Huff and former Cy Young Award-winning pitcher Jake Peavy.
This fall, the program’s biggest challenge is simply getting enough healthy bodies onto the field. If the bye week does what Barnett hopes, the Saints will head to Montgomery with a new-look offense and a chance to start a late-season push.
Related coverage from South AL News
- McGill-Toolen Scores Final 14 Points to Beat St. Paul’s 34-24 in Region Opener
- UMS-Wright blanks St. Paul's 31-0 in Battle of Old Shell Road for 700th win
- A Backup Quarterback Ran for Four Touchdowns and St. Paul's Still Lost: St. Michael Rallies 39-35 as Clarke County Wins No. 30 in a Row
- Week 9 Football Scores: Gunner Rivers Throws 4 TDs, Mary G. Montgomery Stops Daphne's 2-Point Try
