Prichard Evidence Room Photos Fuel Bid to Throw Out DNA in Mobile Rape Case
Lawyers for Willie Henry Ervin cite photos of Prichard's evidence room and an altered warrant application in asking a judge to exclude DNA evidence. Prosecutors say the sample was sent to the state lab almost immediately.
Update, Oct. 26: At a hearing Monday, Judge Ben Brooks heard more arguments over disputed evidence in Willie Henry Ervin’s rape case but held off on a ruling until he hears from police officers who were not available. The judge excluded one piece of evidence that prosecutors conceded, gave the state 30 days for more written arguments and set another hearing for December. Details are below.
Latest developments: Judge wants to hear from officers
Ervin’s lawyers with the Mobile County Public Defender’s Office have added specific allegations that the chain of custody, the record of who handled evidence and when, was not maintained. They told Brooks on Monday, Oct. 26, that they believe gaps in the custody record suggest some evidence was tampered with.
Prosecutors must show who processed, analyzed and stored evidence to establish that it was not corrupted. Mobile County District Attorney Keith Blackwood said questions about chain of custody typically affect how much weight a jury gives evidence, not whether it can be admitted, and that challenges are an inevitable result of the well-publicized problems in the Prichard Police Department.
Blackwood said they expected challenges to chain of custody and other issues in these cases and are prepared for them, including in this case, ready to meet any challenge or argue any chain of custody arguments that arise.
Questions about one officer’s handling of evidence
Ervin’s lawyers say there is no written record showing how then-Officer Brian Lacey took possession of evidence from the motel room that he delivered to the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences for comparison with Ervin’s DNA. Assistant District Attorney Danni Ferris told the judge she is researching whether such a record exists.
She said she is working to see if that exists.
Brooks said the evidence log would be of importance to him.
Lacey separately pleaded guilty to an unrelated third-degree assault charge. Ferris said she is not inclined to call him as a witness but believes she can establish the chain of custody through circumstantial evidence.
‘Rampant corruption’ argument
The defense argued that even if prosecutors establish the chain of custody, the evidence should still be barred because of what it called rampant corruption in the Prichard Police Department. The filing states that to date, at least seven officers of the Prichard Police have been arrested, with at least five already indicted, and that extortion, bribery, tampering with evidence, and use of office for personal gain have come to define the department in the public perception. It includes mug shots of the seven officers and a news story on Lacey’s arrest quoting Blackwood’s criticism of the department for keeping him on the force.
Blackwood said at the time that it surprised him that he is still employed.
One item excluded; next hearing in December
Brooks excluded one piece of evidence that the district attorney’s office conceded: part of a holster for a Sig Sauer firearm found in the room. The defense said officers did not properly document who handled it or how it was stored. The judge gave prosecutors 30 days to file additional written arguments on the remaining issues and will hold another hearing in December.
Blackwood said chain-of-custody issues come up in many cases, not only those handled by Prichard police, and that there are many difficult things they do at the DA’s Office day in and day out, and this is no different.
Ervin, 50, is accused of raping a woman at the Star Motel on Bessemer Avenue in 2023. He is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.
The earlier report follows.
MOBILE, Ala. — Photos of the Prichard evidence room in disarray have become part of a Mobile rape case. A defense lawyer is asking a judge to throw out DNA evidence against his client, arguing that the Prichard Police Department mishandled physical and forensic evidence.
Mobile County Circuit Judge Ben Brooks heard arguments and testimony on the request Wednesday. He said he would wait for written arguments from both sides before ruling.
The case involves Willie Henry Ervin, 50, of Mobile, who is charged with first-degree rape and first-degree sodomy in connection with an assault on a woman at the Star Motel on Bessemer Avenue in Prichard in 2023.
The Allegations
Prichard police alleged that Ervin forced his way into the woman’s motel room, attacked her with a pistol and then raped her. Police said at the time that the victim identified Ervin from a photo lineup.
The charges against Ervin are allegations. He is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court.
Two Lines of Attack on the Evidence
The Mobile County Public Defender’s Office, which represents Ervin, is challenging the DNA evidence on two separate grounds.
The search warrant. The defense argues that someone altered the affidavit and search warrant application in the case, blacking out the name of a different suspect and inserting Ervin’s name. According to the defense filing, it is not clear whether that change was made before or after a magistrate signed off on the warrant.
The handling of evidence. The filing also attacks what it calls the Police Department’s mishandling of physical and forensic evidence. It includes photographs released by the Mobile County Sheriff’s Office showing the Prichard evidence room in disarray.
Attorney Russell Bergstrom wrote that recent news coverage has shown how carelessly and incompetently the Prichard Police Department handled physical and forensic evidence.
Bergstrom argued that photos of the evidence room show a high probability of contamination of evidence.
The Prosecution’s Response
Mobile County Chief Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Susman told the court there was ample justification supporting the warrant, including sworn testimony.
She said that additional testimony cured the defects alleged about the underlying search warrant, so they were confident in the motion as argued.
On the evidence room, Susman said the conditions shown in the photographs had no bearing on Ervin’s case because investigators sent the sample to the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences almost immediately.
She said that was not one of the kits seen languishing in the Prichard evidence room photos, and that if it was returned after that, it didn’t matter because the profile had been created, so any issues or concerns about the horrible pictures seen have nothing to do with Mr. Ervin’s case.
Susman’s argument rests on how DNA testing works. Once a state lab develops a DNA profile from a sample, that profile exists as a record that can be compared against a suspect’s DNA. If the profile was generated before the sample was stored in poor conditions, the prosecution contends, later storage problems would not change the result.
A New Cheek Swab
Brooks on Thursday ordered Ervin to submit to another cheek swab, a quick, painless way of collecting a DNA sample from the inside of a person’s mouth.
The judge also asked both sides to submit written arguments on two questions: whether the original DNA evidence should be thrown out, and whether the results of the newly administered test could be admitted at trial.
A fresh sample taken under a court order could give the prosecution a path to DNA evidence that does not depend on the original search warrant or on the chain of custody inside the Prichard Police Department. The defense is expected to address whether the new test should be allowed in its written arguments.
Why a Search Warrant Challenge Matters
Under the Fourth Amendment, evidence obtained through an invalid search warrant can be suppressed, meaning prosecutors cannot use it at trial. A warrant must be supported by sworn facts showing probable cause, and it is reviewed and approved by a judge or magistrate.
If a warrant application was altered after a magistrate approved it, the document the magistrate signed would not be the same document that authorized the search. That is the core of the defense’s concern. Prosecutors counter that the sworn testimony supporting the warrant was sufficient to cure any defects the defense has alleged.
The Prichard Police Department Under Scrutiny
The motion arrives as the Prichard Police Department faces intense scrutiny. The Mobile County Sheriff’s Office has handled most policing calls in Prichard since mid-June, when local and federal authorities announced the arrest of a Prichard officer as part of a corruption investigation. Several more officers have since been arrested, including Chief Walter Knight.
The sheriff’s office released the photographs of the evidence room that the defense has now attached to its filing. Prichard officials, meanwhile, have been working to hire a new police chief and rebuild the department, and the Mobile County district attorney has called for the city to abolish its police department.
Defense attorneys in other cases investigated by Prichard police could raise similar questions about the handling of evidence. How Brooks rules in Ervin’s case may offer an early sign of how courts will weigh the evidence room conditions against the specific facts of individual cases.
What Happens Next
Brooks is waiting for written arguments from the prosecution and defense before deciding whether the original DNA evidence will be excluded and whether the new cheek swab results may be used.
Ervin’s trial is set for Oct. 26.
Anyone affected by sexual violence can reach the National Sexual Assault Hotline 24 hours a day at 800-656-4673.
Related coverage from South AL News
- Missing Prichard Police Evidence Contributed to Dismissal of 2022 Double-Murder Case, DA Says
- Rocket Docket Sends Gethsemane Cemetery Murder Case to Grand Jury as Motive Remains Unknown
- Missing Video, $6,400 in Cash and a Fifth Amendment Claim: Defense Seeks New Trial in Prichard Nightclub Killing
- Mobile County Grand Jury Indicts Prichard Police Chief, Sergeant After Misconduct Probe
