Eight Mile Arrest in $130,000 Memorabilia Theft: Two Vehicles Full of Signed Guitars and Jerseys Recovered

Semmes police arrested Tristan Cowart in Eight Mile in connection with a $130,000 sports memorabilia theft, recovering about $75,000 in property including dozens of signed guitars from two vehicles.

By James Bullard

September 19, 2026 · 5:00 pm Updated October 31, 2026 4 min read

EIGHT MILE, Ala. — Semmes police have arrested a suspect in connection with the theft of $130,000 worth of sports memorabilia and collectibles, taking the case from a shop owner’s tip in late August to an arrest and a substantial recovery of property.

Authorities arrested Tristan Cowart in Eight Mile, charging him with receiving stolen property and driving with a suspended license.

Two Vehicles Full of Collectibles

During the arrest, investigators reported finding two vehicles filled with stolen goods, including dozens of signed guitars, sports memorabilia and other rare collectibles.

The items are believed to have been taken from Colony Storage. Police said they have recovered about $75,000 worth of stolen property.

Recovering roughly $75,000 of an estimated $130,000 in stolen goods is a meaningful result in a case of this type. Memorabilia is difficult property to recover once it disperses, because individual items move quickly through private sales, online marketplaces, pawn shops and card shows, and because items frequently pass to buyers with no reason to suspect anything is wrong.

How the Case Started

The investigation began last month after a store owner in Spanish Fort noticed stolen jerseys that a woman was attempting to sell.

That detail is the hinge of the entire case. Signed memorabilia is a specialist market, and the people who deal in it professionally know which collections exist locally and what is unusual to see walk through the door. A complete set of autographed jerseys or a run of high-grade vintage cards appearing without provenance is exactly the kind of anomaly that a shop owner recognizes and a general secondhand buyer would not.

The Charges

Cowart is charged with receiving stolen property and driving with a suspended license.

Receiving stolen property is a distinct offense from theft under Alabama law. It applies to a person who receives, retains or disposes of stolen property knowing or having reasonable grounds to believe it was stolen, and who does not intend to return it to the owner. The degree of the charge is graded by the value of the property, with higher values producing felony classifications.

Charging receiving stolen property rather than theft does not necessarily indicate investigators believe a suspect was uninvolved in the original taking. It is frequently the charge supported by the evidence at the time of arrest — possession of the property — while the investigation into the underlying theft continues.

Bond and Court Date

Cowart is being held on a $7,500 bond and is scheduled to appear in court Wednesday.

Police noted that the investigation remains active and additional charges could be filed.

Why Storage Units Are a Target

The property is believed to have been taken from Colony Storage. Self-storage facilities present a specific security problem for high-value property: they are designed for volume and access rather than for protecting individual valuable collections, units are typically secured by a padlock the renter supplies, and a facility may not know what any given unit contains.

Collectors are often advised to photograph and inventory items individually, record serial numbers and certification numbers where they exist, maintain documentation of authentication, and confirm whether a homeowner’s or renter’s policy covers property stored off-premises — many do not, or cover it only to a low sublimit. Detailed records are also what allows law enforcement to identify recovered property as belonging to a specific owner rather than holding it as unidentified goods.

What Happens Next

Cowart has not been convicted and is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty in court. Police said the case remains open and further charges are possible as the investigation continues.

Anyone who believes they may have purchased items connected to the theft is encouraged to contact the Semmes Police Department.

Update: $75,000 in Items Recovered and Returned

As of Friday, Sept. 18, Semmes Police Department officers have recovered $75,000 worth of the stolen items, which has been returned to the victim.

Tristan Cowart, 43, is charged with first-degree receiving stolen property.

How the Case Developed

Officers were called to Colony Storage on Thursday, Sept. 17, for a report of several burglaries amounting to $130,000 in sports and music memorabilia.

Searching the area, officers located a vehicle at a home at the intersection of Dossett Road and Brunson Lane that belonged to the suspect. Cowart was arrested and two vehicles were impounded before a search warrant was obtained for them.

During the search of the vehicles, officials said they found a substantial portion of the stolen property, including 15 pieces of sports memorabilia, 36 signed guitars and what officers described as numerous other rare and valuable sports memorabilia collectibles.

The Charge

First-degree receiving stolen property in Alabama is a Class B felony, applying when the value of the property involved exceeds the statutory threshold. It covers knowingly receiving, retaining or disposing of stolen property, and is frequently charged where a suspect is found in possession of stolen goods.

Officers said the investigation remains active and additional charges are possible. Roughly $55,000 of the reported $130,000 in stolen property has not been accounted for.

Why Recovery Matters in Collectibles Cases

Recovering and returning $75,000 of the property within a day of the initial report is a notably fast outcome for a theft of this kind.

Signed memorabilia presents particular difficulties once it disperses. Value depends heavily on authentication and provenance, items are individually identifiable to their owner but generic to an outside buyer, and resale channels — online marketplaces, shops, private collectors — scatter pieces quickly across jurisdictions. Property recovered from a suspect’s vehicles before it entered those channels is property that can be identified and returned.